Florida’s Sunshine Law has long been considered one of the strongest open-government statutes in the nation. But over the past two decades, a patchwork of exemptions, weakened penalties, and inconsistent enforcement have turned what was once a national model of transparency into something closer to a suggestion than a rule.
State Rep. Alex Andrade (R-Pensacola) is now trying to change that. And not quietly.
In his 2025 bill proposal, Andrade is pushing to restore criminal penalties for willfully violating Florida’s open-meeting and public-records requirements—penalties that defenders of transparency say are long overdue, and opponents claim could chill public service.
From a right-of-center perspective, the proposal reflects a growing trend among conservative reformers: if government can’t be made smaller, it must at least be made more accountable.
A Return to Accountability, Not Bureaucracy
The heart of Andrade’s proposal is simple:
Government officials who knowingly hide public business from the public should face consequences. Real ones.
For years, Sunshine Law violations have been treated as low-grade misdemeanors with little practical consequence. Agencies drag their feet, delay records, inflate costs, or claim exemptions that don’t exist—because there’s effectively no penalty for doing so.
Andrade’s bill would:
- Restore criminal liability for willful violations
- Reinstate mandatory reporting requirements when meetings are improperly held
- Increase deterrence for officials who “accidentally on purpose” conduct public business behind closed doors
- Close loopholes that allow agencies to ignore, delay, or price-gouge record requests
While critics argue this could lead to over-criminalization, conservatives often argue the opposite: power without consequence leads to abuse.
Government transparency, like law enforcement accountability or election integrity, requires enforceable rules—not merely aspirational principles.
Why the Right Should Care About Transparency Reform
Contrary to the caricature put forward by some activists, transparency isn’t a left-wing issue. Not anymore.
Increasingly, right-of-center voters feel that big government, bureaucracy, and political insiders operate without oversight—whether it’s school boards hiding policies, state agencies delaying records, or local governments conducting business in private workshops instead of posted meetings.
Andrade’s bill hits a few important conservative notes:
1. Limits Government Power
Sunshine laws don’t grow government—they restrain it.
2. Exposes Bureaucratic Overreach
If the public can see behind the curtain, agencies can’t hide bad policy or political gamesmanship.
3. Rebuilds Public Trust
After years of institutional mistrust—COVID decisions, school transparency battles, law-enforcement controversies—sunlight reduces speculation and conspiracy simply by making records plainly available.
4. Discourages Back-Room Deals
Business conducted in the open is harder to manipulate.
Developers, unions, consultants, and lobbyists all prefer opacity.
Voters don’t.
Democrats Will Claim This “Criminalizes Governance.” Does It?
Some Democrats already argue Andrade’s proposal will intimidate public officials or deter people from serving. But that argument rests on a flawed premise: that government deserves special protection from accountability the average citizen doesn’t receive.
If a private citizen ignores a subpoena?
If a contractor falsifies documentation?
If a business hides mandatory disclosures?
They face penalties.
Why should government be the exception?
The loudest opponents of Andrade’s bill seem to be the same entities most frequently accused of withholding documents and conducting shadow meetings. That should tell voters everything they need to know.
The Real Fight: Enforcement vs. Evasion
Strengthening the Sunshine Law isn’t just about transparency. It’s about the political culture in Florida.
Florida has seen:
- School boards accused of holding improper “workshops” outside public scrutiny
- County commissions communicating through private group chats
- State agencies stonewalling record requests for months
- Local governments using excessive fees to block access to documents
Republicans have increasingly been on the receiving end of these tactics—especially in Democrat-controlled counties and school districts. Andrade’s bill would give conservatives (and everyone else) a way to finally push back when government hides the ball.
Conclusion: A Conservative Transparency Pivot Worth Watching
For years, Florida’s Sunshine Law has been swollen with loopholes, exceptions, and excuses. Reestablishing criminal penalties isn’t “big government”—it’s a reassertion that government answers to its citizens, not the other way around.
Whether the bill passes will depend on how many lawmakers want transparency versus how many prefer the comfort of the back room.
But one thing is clear:
Rep. Alex Andrade just reignited the Sunshine Law debate, and he did it from a direction Florida hasn’t seen in a long time—conservative, principled transparency.
If Florida’s lawmakers truly believe in accountability, this is their moment to prove it.
Florida Bay News 
Leave a comment